Facts:
Paz, a Filipino citizen, was the widow of one Jose Hernandez. In 1934, she married Alejandro Ang Chay, a Chinese. Of this second marriage, two daughters, Josefina and Mercedita were born. In 1939, however, Paz and Alejandro agreed to live separately from each other, with the two children remaining with Paz.
Paz enrolled the two girls in school as "Josefina Hernandez" and "Mercedita Hernandez". They graduated from college, obtained employment, paid income taxes, and exercised voting privilege under the same name. The two had always been of the belief that they were Filipinos until January 1966, when their mother disclosed to them that their father is a Chinese and their true surname is Ang Chay.
In 1966, Josefina and Mercedita file a petition praying for the change of their respective names to Josefina Hernandez and Mercedita Hernandez. They would like to use Filipino names by having their surnames "Ang Chay" changed to "Hernandez". The trial court granted the petition.
Issue:
Should petitioners be allowed to continue using the surname Hernandez?
Held:
Change of name is not a matter of right; that being a privilege, before it can be authorized, the person petitioning for such change must first show proper cause or compelling reason therefor. And what may constitute as proper and compelling reason shall depend on the particular circumstances of each case, and upon the discretion of the trial court.
In the present proceeding, there is valid reason to justify the continued use by petitioners of the names by which they have been known, and with which they have always conducted, in good faith, their various social and business activities. Petitioners had no knowledge whatsoever that their father is a Chinese and that their surnames properly should be "Ang Chay". Petitioners have been carrying the family name "Hernandez". They finished their schooling and got employments, voted in the local and national elections, and paid their income taxes, under that surname.
It is not difficult to understand that for them to start using the family name "Ang Chay" at this time would cause no little amount of confusion and trouble in the lives of these girls, who do not appear to have any hand at all in creating the situation they now find themselves in. Besides there is nothing on the record to intimate that herein petitioners' use of the surname "Hernandez" would cause damage or prejudice, either to the government or to any other private party, including their mother's children by the first marriage. For, as this Court has succinctly declared, a mere change of name would not cause a change in one's existing family relations, nor create new family rights and duties where none exists before. Neither would it affect a person's legal capacity, civil status or citizenship. What would only be altered is the word or group of words by which he is identified and distinguished from the rest of his fellow men. Thus, this Court, in some meritorious cases, granted the applications of naturalized Filipinos for change of their foreign names to Filipino-sounding ones, in order that the handicap in their social and business dealings, posed by their alien names, may be removed and thus enable their full integration into the Philippine society where they now belong. There is more compelling reason, therefore, for the granting of this petition and allowing the use of Filipino names by herein petitioners, whose mother is a Filipino, and who have been reared and schooled, and have actually lived, as Filipinos. (Ang Chay et al. vs. Republic, G.R. No. L-28507, July 31, 1970).
Paz, a Filipino citizen, was the widow of one Jose Hernandez. In 1934, she married Alejandro Ang Chay, a Chinese. Of this second marriage, two daughters, Josefina and Mercedita were born. In 1939, however, Paz and Alejandro agreed to live separately from each other, with the two children remaining with Paz.
Paz enrolled the two girls in school as "Josefina Hernandez" and "Mercedita Hernandez". They graduated from college, obtained employment, paid income taxes, and exercised voting privilege under the same name. The two had always been of the belief that they were Filipinos until January 1966, when their mother disclosed to them that their father is a Chinese and their true surname is Ang Chay.
In 1966, Josefina and Mercedita file a petition praying for the change of their respective names to Josefina Hernandez and Mercedita Hernandez. They would like to use Filipino names by having their surnames "Ang Chay" changed to "Hernandez". The trial court granted the petition.
Issue:
Should petitioners be allowed to continue using the surname Hernandez?
Held:
Change of name is not a matter of right; that being a privilege, before it can be authorized, the person petitioning for such change must first show proper cause or compelling reason therefor. And what may constitute as proper and compelling reason shall depend on the particular circumstances of each case, and upon the discretion of the trial court.
In the present proceeding, there is valid reason to justify the continued use by petitioners of the names by which they have been known, and with which they have always conducted, in good faith, their various social and business activities. Petitioners had no knowledge whatsoever that their father is a Chinese and that their surnames properly should be "Ang Chay". Petitioners have been carrying the family name "Hernandez". They finished their schooling and got employments, voted in the local and national elections, and paid their income taxes, under that surname.
It is not difficult to understand that for them to start using the family name "Ang Chay" at this time would cause no little amount of confusion and trouble in the lives of these girls, who do not appear to have any hand at all in creating the situation they now find themselves in. Besides there is nothing on the record to intimate that herein petitioners' use of the surname "Hernandez" would cause damage or prejudice, either to the government or to any other private party, including their mother's children by the first marriage. For, as this Court has succinctly declared, a mere change of name would not cause a change in one's existing family relations, nor create new family rights and duties where none exists before. Neither would it affect a person's legal capacity, civil status or citizenship. What would only be altered is the word or group of words by which he is identified and distinguished from the rest of his fellow men. Thus, this Court, in some meritorious cases, granted the applications of naturalized Filipinos for change of their foreign names to Filipino-sounding ones, in order that the handicap in their social and business dealings, posed by their alien names, may be removed and thus enable their full integration into the Philippine society where they now belong. There is more compelling reason, therefore, for the granting of this petition and allowing the use of Filipino names by herein petitioners, whose mother is a Filipino, and who have been reared and schooled, and have actually lived, as Filipinos. (Ang Chay et al. vs. Republic, G.R. No. L-28507, July 31, 1970).
1 Comments
Magnificent items from you, man. I've take into account your stuff prior to and you are just too magnificent. I really like what you have received here, really like what you're saying and the best way by which you say it. You make it entertaining and you continue to take care of to keep it sensible. I can not wait to learn much more from you. This is really a terrific website. divorce paralegal near me
ReplyDeletePost a Comment